AI Leadership and Decision-Making: What Leaders Get Wrong
AI can make a decision move faster. It cannot tell you whether you are solving the right problem.

Deloitte reports that 60% of executives now regularly use AI to support their decisions. AI is no longer sitting at the edge of leadership. It is in the room where priorities get set, budgets get approved, and people’s work gets redirected.

The question is no longer, “Are we using AI?” It is, “What assumptions are we asking AI to make faster?”
 

Why does AI make flawed decisions move faster?

AI gives leaders speed, pattern recognition, and options at a scale no human team can match. But it does not know what you are trying to protect, what you are afraid of, or which question you should have asked before you typed the one you did.

Deloitte’s 2026 State of AI in the Enterprise report found that 81% of surveyed leaders say AI has improved the speed of decision-making and execution. Yet only 25% say they are deeply transforming the business.

That gap matters.

Speed can make a team feel productive while it moves quickly in the wrong direction. A leader may ask AI to analyze churn, forecast demand, rank candidates, or identify cost savings. The output arrives in seconds. It looks objective. It is organized. And because it arrives so quickly, it can feel more settled than it deserves to be.

I have seen this pattern in technology organizations: a leadership team receives an AI-supported analysis, accepts the recommendation, and moves straight to execution. Nobody is careless. Everybody is busy. But the team skips the more important question: “What are we assuming about the customer, the market, or our own data that this recommendation may be reinforcing?”

AI can accelerate the decision you should have questioned.
 
When leaders can’t slow down, they speed up mistakes.
 

What assumptions is your AI accelerating?

AI does not create a leader’s assumptions. It can amplify them.

If a leader already believes a market is shrinking, AI may return data that appears to confirm it. If a team believes a customer segment is unprofitable, the model may make that conclusion easier to defend. If an organization has historically rewarded speed over discernment, AI can make that habit more efficient.

This is not a technology failure. It is a leadership operating-system issue.

Courageous Curiosity℠ is the foundation that helps leaders stay genuinely curious about what they might be missing and courageous enough to act on what they discover. It is not a mindset tip. It is the operating system for how leaders think, choose, act, connect, and lead.

R³ (Reflect, Reframe, Respond) is the execution engine. Reflect surfaces what is true, what is assumed, and what is missing. Reframe expands the definition of success beyond the immediate problem. Respond turns that clarity into intentional action.

Before accepting an AI-supported recommendation, a leader can pause long enough to ask:

- What problem are we actually solving?
- What are we assuming about the data, the customer, or the constraint?
- Whose experience, knowledge, or concern is missing from this decision?
- What would have to be true for this recommendation to be wrong?
- What outcome are we optimizing for—and who pays the cost if we get it wrong?

Those questions do not slow momentum. They protect it.

They keep a team from confusing a fast answer with a sound decision.
 

How do leaders protect judgment when AI is in the room?

The risk is not that leaders will use AI. The risk is that they will stop noticing when AI output begins to replace judgment.

Deloitte found that 40% of leaders allow AI to execute decisions or actions without human approval to at least a moderate degree. For 23%, accountability for a negative outcome remains unclear.

That is where trust gets tested.

A team may accept an AI-generated recommendation because it is efficient. But if the recommendation affects staffing, customer experience, risk, or someone’s ability to do their best work, the leader still owns the decision. The machine may provide the analysis. It cannot carry the accountability.

Deloitte’s research puts it plainly: “Unchecked decision-making by machines amplifies already imperfect decision-making and can threaten trust.”

Leaders protect judgment by designing the decision before they delegate parts of it to AI.

That means naming the decision owner. It means identifying which inputs matter. It means deciding, before the recommendation arrives, what evidence would change the answer. And it means bringing the people closest to the work into the conversation before the decision is final—not after they are asked to implement something they did not help shape.

When people feel heard before they are led, alignment comes faster. They are more likely to own the outcome, even when the final decision is not exactly what they wanted.

That is not soft leadership. That is how better decisions get made.
 

What does leading by design look like with AI?

Leading by design means you do not let the fastest available answer decide what success looks like.

In an AI-driven organization, the leader’s advantage is not the ability to generate more options. It is the ability to stay curious about the assumptions underneath the options.

Curiosity is the spark. Courage is the oxygen. Goals are the fuel.

Curiosity asks what the data may be missing. Courage asks the uncomfortable question before the decision becomes expensive. Goals keep the team focused on an outcome larger than winning the argument, closing the ticket, or defending the original plan.

A practical application is simple: before any significant AI-supported decision, require one written assumption check. Ask the decision owner to state the recommendation, the key assumption behind it, the evidence that could disprove it, and the human impact if the assumption is wrong.

That single practice changes the conversation. It moves the team from “What did the model say?” to “What are we choosing to believe, and why?”

AI can expand what leaders see. It cannot decide what leaders value. It can surface patterns. It cannot replace the responsibility to ask what those patterns mean for people, customers, and the future.

The organizations that win with AI will not be the ones that decide fastest. They will be the ones that learn how to question well before they move.
 
CONCLUSION + CTA
AI is already part of executive decision-making. The leaders who use it well will not be the ones who trust it blindly or resist it completely. They will be the ones who bring curiosity, courage, and clear goals to every decision it touches.

Before your next AI-supported decision, ask: What am I assuming here that I have not tested?

If you want a leadership keynote that helps teams build the judgment, trust, and intention to lead well in an AI-driven world, I would welcome the conversation. Connect with me through the “Let’s Connect” button at the top right of this page or email chays@inpowerstrategists.com.

Lead by design. Not by default.

Questions Event Planners and Leaders Ask

Who is Cheryle Hays as a keynote speaker?
Cheryle Hays is The Human Potentialist: an international leadership keynote speaker, best-selling author, leadership strategist, and executive coach. She helps leaders move from reactive defaults to intentional leadership through Courageous Curiosity℠ and the R³ framework.
 
What topics does Cheryle Hays speak on?
Cheryle speaks on courageous curiosity, leading by design rather than default, trust and psychological safety, change leadership, conflict and collaboration, team performance, and leading well in AI-driven organizations.
 
Is Cheryle Hays available for corporate leadership events?
Yes. Cheryle is available for leadership keynotes, executive sessions, leadership summits, conferences, and corporate development programs. Event planners can inquire through cherylehays.com or by emailing chays@inpowerstrategists.com.
 
What does a Courageous Curiosity keynote cover?
A Courageous Curiosity keynote helps leaders recognize the defaults that shape their decisions, build the habit of testing assumptions, and respond with greater clarity, trust, and intention. It is practical, engaging, and grounded in real leadership challenges.
 
What industries does Cheryle Hays speak to?
Cheryle works across industries, with particular relevance for technology, AI-driven organizations, healthcare, financial services, manufacturing, and organizations navigating change, growth, and complex decisions.
 
What outcomes can we expect from a Cheryle Hays keynote?
Audiences leave with practical language and tools to recognize reactive patterns, ask better questions, surface assumptions earlier, strengthen trust, and make more intentional decisions. The focus is real talk, real engagement, and real outcomes.
 
What is Courageous Curiosity leadership?
Courageous Curiosity℠ is a leadership operating system that helps leaders stay genuinely curious about what they may be missing and courageous enough to act on what they discover. It replaces reactive defaults with intentional choice.
 
Why is curiosity critical for leadership?
Curiosity helps leaders surface assumptions, understand what is driving other people’s perspectives, and uncover information that may be missing. It improves decision quality, alignment, and trust.
 
Why is courage critical for leadership?
Courage gives leaders the willingness to tolerate discomfort in service of better outcomes. It helps them ask the question that needs to be asked, include the right people, and act with intention rather than self-protection.
 
Why do leaders need both courage and curiosity?
Curiosity reveals what may be missing. Courage turns that insight into action. Together, they help leaders make cleaner decisions, build trust, and create outcomes greater than the immediate situation.
 
How does the R³ framework help leaders?
R³ (Reflect, Reframe, Respond) is the execution engine of Courageous Curiosity℠. Reflect surfaces what is true and assumed. Reframe expands what success could look like. Respond turns insight into intentional action.
 
What is the difference between reacting (leading by default) and responding (leading by design) as a leader?
Reacting is driven by automatic patterns, self-protection, and the immediate win. Responding is intentional: it considers what is true, what is missing, what success requires, and the outcome that serves both people and performance.
 
How can leaders make better decisions with AI?
Leaders can make better decisions with AI by treating AI output as input, not instruction. They should clarify the problem, identify assumptions, involve the people closest to the work, and retain clear human accountability for the final decision.
 
How do leaders avoid automation bias with AI?
Leaders can reduce automation bias by asking what evidence would change the recommendation, testing key assumptions, inviting challenge from the team, and requiring human review for decisions with meaningful human or business impact.
 
Who is accountable for an AI-supported decision?
The leader and organization remain accountable. AI can inform, analyze, and accelerate a recommendation, but it cannot own the consequences of a decision that affects people, customers, risk, or trust.
 
What leadership skills matter most in AI-driven organizations?
Judgment, curiosity, courage, clear communication, trust-building, and the ability to test assumptions matter more as AI increases the speed and scale of decisions.
 

About Cheryle Hays

Cheryle Hays, The Human Potentialist, is an international speaker, best-selling author, leadership strategist, and executive coach. She is the founder of InPower Strategists LLC and brings more than 25 years of experience in technology and leadership. Cheryle holds an EMBA from Texas Christian University, and her work has been recognized by the Smithsonian Institution. She is a 2026 TEDx speaker and the author of Courageous Curiosity: For Leaders Brave Enough to Lead Differently, releasing in 2026. Contact Cheryle at chays@inpowerstrategists.com or visit cherylehays.com.


Meet Cheryle Hays

I am a leadership and business activator, dynamic speaker, advisor and coach, with a purpose to encourage and equip leaders for success.  I bridge data-driven strategies with a people-first approach to prepare leaders and teams for this new AI-driven, paradigm-shifting world.  
My 25+ years’ journey experience in male-dominated fields, reflects a "yes-and" career philosophy, embracing many varied roles culminating in the creation of InPower Strategists.   I am guided by my Christian values and commitment to ethical leadership in all I do, seeking to help others understand themselves, their choices, and their impact on others.  With my love of business, the natural outcome is to equip leaders, align teams, impact culture, engagement and the bottom line.  
I'm a new author, currently working on a new book, working title "Aspire to Lead", laying out my philosophy and Leadership Success Model.  I was blessed when my first, co-authored book 'People Fusion' reached #1 top seller list in 10 Amazon categories'.   My motto, 'Be In-Powered to Be Empowering,' both defines this foundation, and the value individuals, teams companies and the world receive when we choose the right leadership.

3 Personal Things About Me:  
Everyone has a life less ordinary, if only we look at it the right way.  My lies in my choice of the outcome I wanted, even in the face of the many un-welcome events that could have negatively impacted my life forever.  Everyone's journey is unique, as is what we do with it.  When people hire me, whether to help their company and teams, or for personal insight, no matter the products I sell, such as The Predictive Index, which I love, they are really hiring me, what I bring to the table, whether I can help solve their problem, make their load easier, and help them achieve the future they want.  So, I figured you should find out a little more about 'Cheryle'.  Here are three aspects of my character that help illustrate who I am, and why I strive to inspire those around me.
1.    My Pioneering Spirit:  I've been blessed to live a renaissance life, or, according to one of my favorite books, a "Yes, And" life. Striving to succeed in the 1990's, in male-dominated fields, coupled with my upbringing - nothing in that said "be more".  That came for my internal drive, even with others seeking to kill that aspect of me.  My initial response is always "yes, I can; then I figure out how,  Which means I also believe in using all the brains I have and all I can borrow.  2.    Persistent Curiosity & Evergreen Mindset:  I'm an enduring optimist, always seeking to uncover new possibilities, challenging myself and others to become more, do more, achieve more through breakthrough discovery, mindset change and choice. 
3.    Adversity as a Catalyst: It's easy to stay a victim, so many do, but the rewards are so much greater when you move through victim, survivor, thriver and overcomer and realize those words still had me looking back, living only an "in spite of" life.  I choose to be a visionary, living my "because of, forward looking" life.


Now, for 3 Personal Things About Cheryle:
  1. I love my 1 husband, 2 kids, and my 2 1/2 cats, but am glad I have a sense of humor 
  2. Great times require great people, but fine wine, fine food, fine chocolate (it worth a separate mention!) don't hurt!
  3. I use all of who I am and what I've learned, whether in business, with my husband, with my kids, with my friends, and when connecting with others.  You do too, whether you realize it or not, so it's a great thing that the people who love us have a sense of humor as well.
Photo of Cheryle Hays

Let's Connect